Queensland Spanish mackerel under threat

[Lucky_Phill]

https://www.daf.qld.gov.au/business-...17-18-may-2021

Communique 17-18 May 2021
The inaugural East Coast Spanish Mackerel Working Group met on 17 and 18 May 2021 in Brisbane. This was the first meeting of the newly appointed working group. The purpose of the meeting was to provide information on the Sustainable Fisheries Strategy, review the current management and stock issues and commence discussions on developing a harvest strategy for this fishery.
Members were invited to provide a general update from the region or the sector they represent. Several members commented on the issue of shark depredation, which is thought to be a wide-spread issue affecting other fisheries across multiple jurisdictions. Members generally agreed that large numbers of Spanish mackerel are lost to depredation and supported further research to quantify the extent of depredation, identify the species responsible and better understand what is driving the apparent increased prevalence of shark interactions.
Members also raised other issues that may impact on the abundance of Spanish mackerel, including seasonality and environmental drivers of recruitment such as water quality, urban development and oceanographic changes. While these may impact Spanish mackerel stocks, they are outside the control of Fisheries Queensland and need to be accounted for in management arrangements. Some members raised bycatch and discarding in other fisheries that are incidentally capturing Spanish mackerel and contributing to overall fishing mortality (for example, net fisheries). Other issues that were raised included the need to account for managing different types of recreational fishers – those that may incidentally catch Spanish mackerel (as part of reef line fishing activities) and those that may target Spanish mackerel, the abundance and management of bait fish and the need for management intervention in the short-term.
The working group noted information to help inform a shared understanding of the status of east coast Spanish mackerel stocks. It was noted that the commercial harvest has averaged 300 tonnes annually since 2004, however total harvest is well below the current total allowable commercial catch (TACC) for the species. It was noted that Fisheries Queensland’s monitoring programs are picking up increased recreational fishing participation and current east coast Spanish mackerel recreational harvest is estimated to be approximately 170 tonnes.
The working group was provided a preliminary presentation on the results of the 2021 east coast Spanish mackerel stock assessment (not yet published) and how this will inform future decision making in the fishery. Fisheries Queensland advised the draft biomass for Spanish mackerel is estimated to be 17% of unfished biomass. The working group noted the limit reference point of 20% unfished biomass is the point below which a fishery is recommended to be closed under the Sustainable Fisheries Strategy and under National Guidelines. While there are some uncertainties, this is a complex stock assessment with good confidence about the outputs. Industry members noted concerns that a new stock assessment model was used, which produced lower biomass estimates than the previous assessment in 2018.
The working group noted that the stock assessment is currently undergoing independent scientific peer review, which will also be published in coming months. The working group requested more detail on projections for different rebuilding strategies for discussion at the next meeting. Given the stock is shared with New South Wales the working group felt it was important to invite them to attend the next meeting to discuss rebuilding strategies.
Fisheries Queensland provided a presentation on the methodology and outcomes from the BDO social and economic indicators report for commercial and charter fisheries. The working group noted the social and economic indicators dashboard that is available on the department’s website is an important tool for businesses to view performance of the fishery. While the fishery’s economic performance is not positive, all members agreed that this information is important in assessing the performance of the fishery, and when considering the economic impacts of management or other changes.
The working group were presented with an overview of the current management arrangements in place for Spanish mackerel. Given the low biomass estimate, the working group agreed that the management arrangements and fishing rules for all sectors would need to be reviewed to inform management interventions and a rebuilding strategy for this stock.
All members noted the importance of Spanish mackerel for local supply of fish, particularly in regional Queensland where the species is popular. Given the status of the stock, the working group asked about the feasibility of making changes ahead of the 1 July 2021 fishing season, starting in 6 weeks. Fisheries Queensland provided information on the process to review management of this stock and develop a harvest strategy ahead of the 1 July 2022 fishing season. The working group agreed that management change needed to be in place as soon as possible noting that it was likely to be significant and consultation with other stakeholders would be required. The working group noted the need for a number of meetings in 2021 to consider management options for further consultation later in 2021.
Fisheries Queensland provided information on the monitoring and research programs that are in place for the Spanish mackerel fishery. The working group noted the extensive monitoring data over a long time series for east coast Spanish mackerel, with 13% of the commercial catch represented in the data set over the last 10 years. This is higher than many other fisheries, and members noted the continued contribution of commercial and recreational fishers in volunteering this information and the good working relationship with the Fishery Monitoring team. The working group recognised the importance of the combined data collected from commercial fishers and recreational fishers, which provides more confidence about the science underpinning both the status and management of this stock. The working group were keen to see this level of monitoring continue.
The next meeting will be in late June or early July. Members have sought some information on rebuilding projections, how recreational harvest is calculated, release mortality, environmental influences, fishing effort (for example, standardised catch rates), targeting behaviour between the coral reef line and Spanish mackerel fisheries and biological information from monitoring and research. The next meeting will focus on working through possible management interventions, stock rebuilding strategies and initial development of a harvest strategy.
The Spanish Mackerel Working Group members are: Animal Science Queensland (Chair – Sian Breen), Fisheries Queensland (Director, Management and Reform – Kimberly Foster, Principal Fishery Manager – Tony Ham, Senior Fishery Manager – Darren Roy, Fisheries Manager – Ash Lawson, Fisheries Scientist – Joanne Langstreth, Queensland Boating and Fisheries Patrol – Chris Morrison), commercial fishing (Chris Hain, Tony Lanzi, Anthony Vass, Richard Gilmore), recreational fishing (Ryan Tully, Gary Powis, William Bowtell), Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (Darren Cameron) and conservation sector (Debbie Chamberlain).

There is a clear indication, Queenslands Spanish Mackerel Fishery will be shut down. A number of key issues are:-

The Chair of this working group and her agenda.

The NSW fishery management ( spanish mack is a shared resource between NSW & Qld )

The " new modelling " revealing the current bio mass as at 17%

The lack of a complete tool box offered to FQ to manage the fishery

The sudden status of the fishery from sustainable / healthy to one in dire straits ?

LP

[Dignity]

https://www.daf.qld.gov.au/business-...17-18-may-2021

Communique 17-18 May 2021
The inaugural East Coast Spanish Mackerel Working Group met on 17 and 18 May 2021 in Brisbane. This was the first meeting of the newly appointed working group. The purpose of the meeting was to provide information on the Sustainable Fisheries Strategy, review the current management and stock issues and commence discussions on developing a harvest strategy for this fishery.
Members were invited to provide a general update from the region or the sector they represent. Several members commented on the issue of shark depredation, which is thought to be a wide-spread issue affecting other fisheries across multiple jurisdictions. Members generally agreed that large numbers of Spanish mackerel are lost to depredation and supported further research to quantify the extent of depredation, identify the species responsible and better understand what is driving the apparent increased prevalence of shark interactions.
Members also raised other issues that may impact on the abundance of Spanish mackerel, including seasonality and environmental drivers of recruitment such as water quality, urban development and oceanographic changes. While these may impact Spanish mackerel stocks, they are outside the control of Fisheries Queensland and need to be accounted for in management arrangements. Some members raised bycatch and discarding in other fisheries that are incidentally capturing Spanish mackerel and contributing to overall fishing mortality (for example, net fisheries). Other issues that were raised included the need to account for managing different types of recreational fishers – those that may incidentally catch Spanish mackerel (as part of reef line fishing activities) and those that may target Spanish mackerel, the abundance and management of bait fish and the need for management intervention in the short-term.
The working group noted information to help inform a shared understanding of the status of east coast Spanish mackerel stocks. It was noted that the commercial harvest has averaged 300 tonnes annually since 2004, however total harvest is well below the current total allowable commercial catch (TACC) for the species. It was noted that Fisheries Queensland’s monitoring programs are picking up increased recreational fishing participation and current east coast Spanish mackerel recreational harvest is estimated to be approximately 170 tonnes.
The working group was provided a preliminary presentation on the results of the 2021 east coast Spanish mackerel stock assessment (not yet published) and how this will inform future decision making in the fishery. Fisheries Queensland advised the draft biomass for Spanish mackerel is estimated to be 17% of unfished biomass. The working group noted the limit reference point of 20% unfished biomass is the point below which a fishery is recommended to be closed under the Sustainable Fisheries Strategy and under National Guidelines. While there are some uncertainties, this is a complex stock assessment with good confidence about the outputs. Industry members noted concerns that a new stock assessment model was used, which produced lower biomass estimates than the previous assessment in 2018.
The working group noted that the stock assessment is currently undergoing independent scientific peer review, which will also be published in coming months. The working group requested more detail on projections for different rebuilding strategies for discussion at the next meeting. Given the stock is shared with New South Wales the working group felt it was important to invite them to attend the next meeting to discuss rebuilding strategies.
Fisheries Queensland provided a presentation on the methodology and outcomes from the BDO social and economic indicators report for commercial and charter fisheries. The working group noted the social and economic indicators dashboard that is available on the department’s website is an important tool for businesses to view performance of the fishery. While the fishery’s economic performance is not positive, all members agreed that this information is important in assessing the performance of the fishery, and when considering the economic impacts of management or other changes.
The working group were presented with an overview of the current management arrangements in place for Spanish mackerel. Given the low biomass estimate, the working group agreed that the management arrangements and fishing rules for all sectors would need to be reviewed to inform management interventions and a rebuilding strategy for this stock.
All members noted the importance of Spanish mackerel for local supply of fish, particularly in regional Queensland where the species is popular. Given the status of the stock, the working group asked about the feasibility of making changes ahead of the 1 July 2021 fishing season, starting in 6 weeks. Fisheries Queensland provided information on the process to review management of this stock and develop a harvest strategy ahead of the 1 July 2022 fishing season. The working group agreed that management change needed to be in place as soon as possible noting that it was likely to be significant and consultation with other stakeholders would be required. The working group noted the need for a number of meetings in 2021 to consider management options for further consultation later in 2021.
Fisheries Queensland provided information on the monitoring and research programs that are in place for the Spanish mackerel fishery. The working group noted the extensive monitoring data over a long time series for east coast Spanish mackerel, with 13% of the commercial catch represented in the data set over the last 10 years. This is higher than many other fisheries, and members noted the continued contribution of commercial and recreational fishers in volunteering this information and the good working relationship with the Fishery Monitoring team. The working group recognised the importance of the combined data collected from commercial fishers and recreational fishers, which provides more confidence about the science underpinning both the status and management of this stock. The working group were keen to see this level of monitoring continue.
The next meeting will be in late June or early July. Members have sought some information on rebuilding projections, how recreational harvest is calculated, release mortality, environmental influences, fishing effort (for example, standardised catch rates), targeting behaviour between the coral reef line and Spanish mackerel fisheries and biological information from monitoring and research. The next meeting will focus on working through possible management interventions, stock rebuilding strategies and initial development of a harvest strategy.
The Spanish Mackerel Working Group members are: Animal Science Queensland (Chair – Sian Breen), Fisheries Queensland (Director, Management and Reform – Kimberly Foster, Principal Fishery Manager – Tony Ham, Senior Fishery Manager – Darren Roy, Fisheries Manager – Ash Lawson, Fisheries Scientist – Joanne Langstreth, Queensland Boating and Fisheries Patrol – Chris Morrison), commercial fishing (Chris Hain, Tony Lanzi, Anthony Vass, Richard Gilmore), recreational fishing (Ryan Tully, Gary Powis, William Bowtell), Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (Darren Cameron) and conservation sector (Debbie Chamberlain).

There is a clear indication, Queenslands Spanish Mackerel Fishery will be shut down. A number of key issues are:-

The Chair of this working group and her agenda.

The NSW fishery management ( spanish mack is a shared resource between NSW & Qld )

The " new modelling " revealing the current bio mass as at 17%

The lack of a complete tool box offered to FQ to manage the fishery

The sudden status of the fishery from sustainable / healthy to one in dire straits ?

LP

The following quote made no sense to me as I understood commercial fisherman had to divest their total catch rates, or have I been mislead?

"The working group noted the extensive monitoring data over a long time series for east coast Spanish mackerel, with 13% of the commercial catch represented in the data set over the last 10 years"

It possibly has some meaning in relation to some data set somewhere but pointless in such a statement on its own

[Lovey80]

Is the chair an ex WWF eco warrior?

I can’t wait to see this new modelling.

[Lucky_Phill]

Is the chair an ex WWF eco warrior?

I can’t wait to see this new modelling.

Sian spent 4 plus years at WWF as Policy manager........

LP

[Lucky_Phill]

Just in:- https://www.daf.qld.gov.au/business-...JoALvzj6p8smGk

n 2020, Fisheries Queensland completed a stock assessment using the most current biological data, and commercial and recreational catch data to:

• determine the sustainability of fish stocks
• inform management decisions.
• inform the development of a harvest strategy.

This assessment estimated that the number of Spanish mackerel (biomass) was between 14% and 27% of unfished levels, and most probably at around 17%.

An independent review of the Spanish mackerel stock assessment was conducted by Dr Neil Klaer, a former CSIRO fisheries scientist. The reviewer agreed the data was used appropriately in the assessment and that the assessment model itself was suitable. The reviewer questioned the model setting for lower resilience in the ability for Spanish mackerel as a species to bounce back after high fishing pressure and was unable to support model predictions until this uncertainty was resolved.

LP

[Lovey80]

So the 2016 Spanish Mackerel Stock assessment using Fisheries own models had the biomass at between 30-50% with a 40% best estimate. By 2020, using a new model, the biomass is between 14-27% with 17% being the best estimate.

I wonder if they ran the 2016 data through the current model to determine what this model spat out the biomass assessment was for 2016. I wonder if it would be higher or lower than the current 17% estimate. It's a little hard to compare two separate estimates using two different models if you are trying to determine what direction a fishery is heading.

The next thing I wonder is how do we have any confidence in them that these models and the corresponding management measures are credible. If for years the "experts" are telling us the biomass is stable and 😁40% of virgin and or that the previous measures were adequate and fisheries knew what they are doing? Going back to 2009 the biomass was supposed to e 51%. then by 2016 40% by 2020 17%.

Two questions need to be asked here.

1. If those numbers truely are accurate how are these managers of the fishery to be considered competent as to listen to a word they say? Its apparently been declining pretty heavily from 50% to 17% in just 11 years? All these measures that have been brought in over the years have seen a decline from 50% to 17% from 2009 to 2020? Did no one eat Spanish mackerel from 1788 all the way through to about 1980? at 23% decline in a decade, its remarkable the Spanish survived this long.
2. If the previous numbers weren't accurate. Why should we now consider their new model accurate? What made them so competent now that they are all of a sudden credible?

[TheGurn]

I'll admit I'm pretty ignorant at all this fish management stuff, but one thing puzzles me.

Apart from the glaringly obvious (like black jew?), it seems they start managing stock levels for species at the top of the food chain (apex predators, sharks), and work their way down.
How's that gonna work?

Hope I'm wrong, but seems to be a self fulfilling prophesy of declining fish stocks.

[fishtragic]

These figures of biomass levels are derived from definitive catch records from commercial fishers and creel surveys from recreational fishers of dubious accuracy, lets call it best estimates. What consideration, if any I wonder, have the researchers given to the impact of shark population, and behavioral, changes. For years now both sectors have been screaming about increasing losses to sharks, in some cases many more taken by the sharks than landed. Let's hope that they do take this into account and formulate a plan to balance the numbers. The tricky part is getting the scientists and regulation makers to not take the kneejerk approach by stopping fishing to reduce the losses to sharks. Surely getting the shark populations back under control would make more sense. I really feel like headbutting the next text book expert that tries to tell me that shark populations are in trouble.

[Dezzer]

Good point!

One of my favourite Fishing the Wild episodes, go girls!





Sent from my CPH1715 using Ausfish mobile app

[Lovey80]

What a cracking show. One of the best.