The door would have had a captive bolt fiberglassed in and a wing init would have held the hatch closed
if the face is perfectly flat go to a plastics place and get them to cut something to shape and bevel the edges a few evenly placed riv nuts means the whole thing would be removable again easily in the future
can add a rubber gasket cut from a sheet from one of those rubber places as the riv nuts means it will sit a few mm proud of the old dash
neat and tidy and no fibreglass work