I agree with most comments to date, a sample of 1 is not a scientifically valid experiment and can lead to claims of bias and error ( I have a background in biostatistics). However, the test is a starting point for further investigation and finding an independent assessor to do this is always difficult in a competitive commercial market. I recall the animosity between Savwinch and Lone Star when I was researching and talking with the vendors at the Melbourne boat show a few years ago. Both were equally critical and making claim and counter claim about each other, almost to the point of legal action. I just wonder about the timing of the test result in view of the boat show coming up this weekend in Melbourne. It would make for some interesting conversation to see if the video is played on the Lone Star stand. In the end I went with Savwinch for my boat based on economic and service back-up reasons as I am a complete mechanical novice. I have experienced one winch motor stall and reset after 30 minutes when anchored in 8m around Mud Island to date. Not sure what to make of it as I was able to break free from the reef, but it does rock your confidence in the product. By the way, I really appreciate the wide experience and advice given by so many Ausfish members on this site. I certainly get more out of the forum than I contribute. Thanks again guys.