View Poll Results: When is a Snapper a Snapper and not a squire??

Voters
277. You may not vote on this poll
  • They all Snappers no matter how small

    112 40.43%
  • They're a Snapper when the pretty dots go

    31 11.19%
  • They're a Snapper when they get a knob on their noggin

    111 40.07%
  • Thy're a Snapper when they don't fit in the landing net

    23 8.30%
Page 7 of 8 FirstFirst 12345678 LastLast
Results 91 to 105 of 106

Thread: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

  1. #91

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    when it melts in your mouth and is juicy without being soppy, its a snapper.

  2. #92

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    When your talking to your mates about your catch .. Nagg

  3. #93

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    u call other peoples fish squire and call your own snapper. i think thats the way it works.
    but seriously, i belieive there are 2 sub species here on the east coast. one can get very large before it develops any bump and also has a slightly smaller eye. the other will develop a large and somtimes even deformed looking bump at a much smaller size. this one also has larger eye.

  4. #94

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    N C T, A very interesting call.
    Not being a big time offshore fisherman I dont have the experience to comment. Photos of catches seem to back up what you say. Big prominant hump on fish barely 4 or 5 kilos, other times a smallish hump on 10 kilo fish....

    I think there may also be a similar geographic sub population of Dusky flathead.

    I think it would help the Icthyol, Ickyolog, Fish geeks if we would all start taking a more or less standardised photo. These days with Digi - who cares - it doesn't cost $, you can still take your big smile & big fish shots, but we have the opportunity to actually document them, almost as good as genotyping samples & otoliths but heapso cheaper.
    Eg: Single Full fish, lying flat on brag mat, or similar easily read measurer.

    I propose all snapper over 7 kilos be photographed on my plate immediately before my consumption.

  5. #95

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    If it hasn't got a knob then it's a squire in my opinion.

  6. #96

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    when its born acording to the authorities

  7. #97

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    They are all snapper to me!!!! Because I can't spell the other name


    Noel

  8. #98

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    It seems to me that we are talking about a acontext sensitive noun, depending on the situation and who you are speaking to what word you use.

    I caught a nice little snapper
    You caught a runt squire.:huh:

    the one that got away.
    to self.... stinkin' little rat
    catchin anything?......just lost a nice little squire.
    to the missus......nearly landed a good sized squire.....mongrel busted me off.
    down the pub.....got busted off by a decent snapper this morning
    After several more.....It was huge red knobby

    What ever you call it...... if its legal it's welcome in my esky... if itys too big for the esky, i'll throw it back.

    now can anybody tell me where they are on the bite and who is doing a good price of BIG eskies

    cheers

  9. #99

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    the knob on the Head has absolutely nothing to do with sub species, age or the size of it's eyes, they are all Snapper, they are born that way and do not change species with age, end of story ,except in QLD for some reason you guys have Squire, might be something to do with being unable to except science or something!

  10. #100

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    if it over 35cm its a keeper and a snapper.

  11. #101

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    There is only 1 species!!!! They are all snapper...derrr

  12. #102

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    Guys

    A snapper is a Snapper no matter what its size. Fisheries do not recognise a fish called Squire.
    So dont get caught saying tht the undersize snapper is a Squire as you will definiately get a on the spot fine.

    Ken

  13. #103

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    Quote Originally Posted by Rodman View Post
    Fisheries do not recognise a fish called Squire.


    Ken
    Yes they do.
    It's a juvenile member of the Pagrus auratus family
    http://www2.dpi.qld.gov.au/fishweb/2532.html
    Last edited by finga; 22-12-2007 at 05:08 PM.
    I intend on living for-ever....so far so good


  14. #104

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    Aren't they all really schnappers???????

  15. #105

    Re: When is a Snapper a Snapper??

    Only when you eat one and wash it down with a glass of Schapps

    Luc

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Join us